Hi dear today I’d love to know if there’s has been research relative to internet decentralization & ecology. The internet’s carbon footprint is already estimated to 10% of global emission. Will decentralization help reduce that or is it paving the way to a worst scenario? Cc @aral @dada @switchingsocial @eliotberriot

@imacrea @aral @dada @switchingsocial @eliotberriot *all the decentralization folks scurry away into dark corners* ;)

No but seriously, it's hard to believe decentralization is more ecological than centralization. There are some choices as society we should make. Personally I believe decentralization is worth it, even if it was less efficient re resources.

Let's concentrate on the *real* big problems instead, oh like:

@jaywink @imacrea @dada @switchingsocial @eliotberriot A peer topology for digital/networked technology (I am not going to use the d-word as the blockchain folks have entirely warped its meaning with their libertarian penis-torches) is a prerequisite for personhood in the digital age. Whether or not we have it will determine whether we are people or property. So I’d say it’s quite fundamental for the future of our species.

@imacrea @aral @jaywink @dada @switchingsocial

Also, centralized services (let's say Gmail) are more critical because they host more content and are basically Single Points Of Failure.

So they end up spending lots of resources on High Availability, Blue/Green deployments, replication, etc. and so on, because every second of downtime is critical.

On the other hand, it's not a big deal if your small Mastodon instance is down for an hour or two.

@imacrea @aral @jaywink @dada @switchingsocial what we call centralized services are actually quite distributed under the hood: data is replicated in multiple datacenters, accross the globe, you have CDNs for delivering content, multiple servers working in parallel to answer your search query, cache systems, etc.

All of this has an ecological cost.

@eliotberriot @imacrea @jaywink @dada @switchingsocial Indeed. What’s centralised is power, ownership, and control. Internally, they will use decentralised architecture to reap its resiliency rewards.

@jaywink I agree on focusing on these giant companies but if they work so well don’t you think it’s also because we’re in such need of energy? If there was pressure on them to, let’s say, produce less then we could expect some stuff to be shutdown on our side. The internet is already estimated to 10% of global emission.

@imacrea For sure we should all play our part. But I highly doubt the #Fediverse is more than peanuts in the sea of the #internet in terms of energy usage.

And then you have things like #Bitcoin which is an ecological disaster.

@imacrea When using transport as a comparison, the #Fediverse is probably something like the energy usage of electric bikes compared to all the cars and trucks :)

@jaywink hmm I don’t know, for sure its usage is far from being massive at the moment. Thanks for your this interesting conversation Jason :)

The main problem is hardware actually. If you read you'll see that AFAICR 10y of electric consumption of the device is roughly equivalent to the production/recycling of the hardware. (And this I think is just about energy, without thinking about resources )

So, if you use a second hand device at home or in a datacenter, you are already a lot better off.

Then, I'd join @aral to say that the centralization of power is unbearable.

So then we have to avoid big centralization like google or facebook.

Hosting at home is not yet practical for everybody from a technical standpoint and the cpu of your machine will likely be a flat <1%.

In our opinion in #chatons and the sweet spot is federation ;)
You have best of both worlds, it is decentralized, in term of energy, the cpu usage is higher. And you can get a beer with your hoster to make sure it is a person that share your values.

@imacrea @aral @dada @switchingsocial @eliotberriot
Out of curiosity, what's your quote for that measure? 10% seems like an awful lot.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
La Quadrature du Net - Mastodon - Media Fédéré

Bienvenue dans le media fédéré de la Quadrature du Net association de défense des libertés. Les inscriptions sont ouvertes et libres.
Tout compte créé ici pourra a priori discuter avec l'ensemble des autres instances de Mastodon de la fédération, et sera visible sur les autres instances.
Nous maintiendrons cette instance sur le long terme.