PifyZ is a user on mamot.fr. You can follow them or interact with them if you have an account anywhere in the fediverse. If you don't, you can sign up here.

It's 2018 and there's no single messaging/chat/instant messaging app that is/has:

* FOSS
* encrypted/security-aware
* plain-text export of all messages for all time
* search across all messages

PifyZ @PifyZ

@vickysteeves Nothing among XMPP (implementations), Matrix (implementations), Tox, Rocket.chat, Mattermost, Wire, Gitter, Signal, Silence, Ring, Delta, Ensichat or Briar (and others) ?

· Web · 0 · 0

@PifyZ I am 80% sure none of these have all 4 criteria, based on my searching! Happy to be proven wrong, but I know 100% that Singal doesn't, gitter doesn't, most stable XMPP implementations don't, and Riot (matrix imp) doesn't.

@PifyZ @vickysteeves XMPP is very awkward when it comes to group chats. Also clients don't work very well when you are in a few rooms... It's really meant for one-on-one (and the resources were a mistake)

@PifyZ @vickysteeves Matrix could be it (decentralized etc) but is soooo inefficient (also mobile app is awful)

@PifyZ @vickysteeves The other ones are either Slack clones (team-oriented, like Mattermost or Rocket.Chat), broken (Gitter, Signal) or don't let me get my data out (Signal, Wire)

@remram44
I mean mattermost satisfies all the criteria given. It's just team oriented IM.
@PifyZ @vickysteeves

@ksteimel @PifyZ @vickysteeves It's not encrypted. The server owner can see and do anything.

@remram44
Ah I didn't realize that even if I encrypted at rest, the keys were still accessible to me.
@PifyZ @vickysteeves